GOURMET COOKIE SHIPPING NOW AVAILABLE DM on IG To Order !
About Us
Passion for Food
At Tastes Like Sugar LLC, we have a deep passion for food and bringing people together. Our founder, Alysha, has always loved baking, cooking and entertaining, which led to the creation of our catering business. Our founder is a Bay Area native and she has been involved with food since the age of 3, starting with Top Ramen.
Always Fresh and Local Ingredients
We take pride in using locally-sourced ingredients for our dishes. This not only supports our local community but also ensures that our food is fresh and of the highest quality.
Sustainability
Sustainability
We are committed to being environmentally conscious in our business practices. From using eco-friendly packaging to reducing food waste, we strive to make a positive impact on the planet.
Tasty Moments of Flavor: A Gallery of Our Delicious Catering Creations
Menu
Small Bites and Shareables
Small meals to share with a friend or have all to yourself !
Shrimp Deviled Eggs (12)
$65/dozen*
Deviled egg filled with diced jumbo shrimp,mayo,egg yolks, mustard,and seasonings. Garnished with a jumbo shrimp smoked paprika and old bay seasoning.
* Must order a minimum of a dozen to place order.
Ground Beef Bouda Balls * NEW ITEM*
3 for $35 , 6 for $55 , Full Pan (9) for $75
A Dirty Rice mixture with bell peppers, ground beef , white rice, shredded cheese, cream cheese, seasonings, all rolled and dusted in a Flaming Hot Cheeto Dust.
Served with a 2 oz. container of homemade creamy cheese sauce.
* Available in Ground Turkey
*Add Shrimp for $7
Carne Asada Bouda Balls * NEW ITEM*
3 for $35 6 for $55 Full Pan (9) for $75
Spanish rice,onions, carne asada meat, shredded cheese, cream cheese, seasonings, all rolled and dusted in a Crushed Tortilla Chips
Served with lime and two 2 oz. container of homemade taco cream sauce.
Hot Cheeto Fried Pickles
5 for $25 , 10 for $35
Juicy Pickle Spears, rolled in Flaming Hot Cheetos served with 2 oz. of Plain Ranch for dipping. This Pairing has the right amount of kick and the Crunch on these will have you coming back for more. Request The Spicy Ranch if you are into Heat!!
Party Dishes
Cheesy Spaghetti
$45 9x13 pan (3-6 servings) $65 Family Size (8-10 Servings)
Spaghetti noodles cooked with 80/20 ground beef, andouille smoked sausage, minced garlic , bell peppers and onions simmered in a sweet and ripe tomato sauce with a topping of melty ooey-gooey cheddar cheese.
WARNING: Please be advised that food prepared may contain these ingredients: milk, eggs, wheat, soybean, peanuts, tree nuts. All sales are final. NO REFUNDS.
Philly Cheesesteak Sliders
$15 each Minimum order : 4
3.5 OUNCES of 100% Sirloin Steak shaved extremely thin grilled with onions and colorful yellow and orange bell peppers topped with slices of sharp provolone cheese all together in a sweet roll.
WARNING: Please be advised that food prepared may contain these ingredients: milk, eggs, wheat, soybean, peanuts, tree nuts. All sales are final. NO REFUNDS.
Shrimp Alfredo
$45-8x8 / $60-family size pan
Jumbo Shrimp with sautéed baby spinach, minced garlic linguine pasta and seasonings tossed in a homemade alfredo sauce. Served with Garlic bread
*Available in chicken
Gumbo
$45/ per bowl $220-family size pan including Crab & Rice
A Flavorful homemade chicken stew with addition of the Holy Trinity pepper mix, creole seasonings, andouille sausage, diced chicken breast, and jumbo shrimp. Paired with a Side of white rice. Crab and other shellfish are optional.
WARNING: Please be advised that food prepared may contain these ingredients: milk, eggs, wheat, soybean, peanuts,, shellfish, tree nuts. All sales are final. NO REFUNDS.
Side Dishes
A la carte
Chicken wings
$45 8x8 pan $95 9x13
Flavors available: Plain, Honey BBQ, Honey Garlic , Lemon Pepper, Buffalo, Sweet Chili, and Jerk Rub
(Minimum Order:1 pan)
5- Cheese Mac n Cheese
$35 8x8 pan $55 family pan
A 5 cheese blend of melty cheeses, seasonings and elbows noodles , so good it'll make your mouth water.
* Seafood can be added although prices may vary
Crab and Shrimp 3 Cheese Mac n Cheese
8x8 Pan - $65 ($100 )9x13 pan
A mouthwatering blend of 3 cheeses, spices, jumbo lump crab meat, jumbo shrimp, and old bay spices.
XL Baked Potatoes
$14
A Fluffy baked potato that has been twice baked, and filled with your selected topping(s). Don't Like Toppings eat it plain with butter, salt and pepper, and green onions.
- Bacon Pieces ($4)
-Shredded Cheese ($2)
- BBQ Sauce ($1)
- Sour Cream ($2)
- Cheese Sauce ($3)
- Sliced Jalapenos ($3)
- 5 Jumbo Prawns ($6)
Sweet Treats
Got A Sweet Tooth 🤤🛑 STOP HERE for homemade desserts
Lemon Raspberry Rolls
$40/ per pan
Homemade Sweet Dough filled with a tart lemon zest cream cheese filling and fresh raspberries, topped with a sweet cream cheese glaze.
Cinnamon Streusel Bars ( FAN FAVORITE )
$38 Per Pan
Cinnamon, Buttery, bars that melt-in-your mouth !
Streusel Bars with cinnamon- brown sugar filling and walnuts* and a cream cheese drizzle.
*May Contain Nuts of traces of tree nuts
Toffee Snickerdoodle Cookies (FAN FAVORITE)
Minimum order: One Dozen ($35)
Cinnamon-sugar butter cookie with toffee pieces in EVERY bite!
Cake Tins
$14 Each
Basic Cake Flavors Available:
- Vanilla
- Chocolate
- Strawberry
- Red Velvet
- Carrot
- Lemon
Specialty Flavors:
- Strawberry- Cheesecake
- Strawberry Tres Leche
- Caramel Mocha
- Cookie Butter Stuffed
- Chocolate- Peanut Butter
- Peach Cobbler Stuffed
- Oreo
Buttercream Flavors:
- Vanilla Bean
- Strawberry
- Lemon
- Chocolate
- Caramel
- Funfetti
- Cream Cheese
- Cookie Butter
- Oreo
* WARNING: Please be advised that food prepared may contain these ingredients: milk, eggs, wheat, soybean, peanuts, tree nuts. All sales are final. NO REFUNDS.
Mini Cheesecakes
(Fan Favorites): Banana Pudding & Caramel Apple)
$35-1/2 Dozen
$55-Full Dozen
*Specialty Dozen- $50
Flavors: Plain, Strawberry, and Double Chocolate
Specialty: S'mores, Chocolate-Peanut Butter, Cookie Butter, Cookies N Cream, Turtle, Peach Cobbler, and Banana Pudding.
Seasonal Flavors: Sweet Potato, and Caramel Apple.
* WARNING: Please be advised that food prepared may contain these ingredients: milk, eggs, wheat, soybean, peanuts, tree nuts. All sales are final.
NO REFUNDS.
Freshly Baked Cookies
Try The Ultimate 3 Pack Today
Half Dozen- $35
Full Dozen-$55
Ultimate 3PACK
(1 C&C,1Twix,1Snicker)- $25
Gourmet Cookie Flavors ($6.00):
- S'mores
- Caramel Milk Chocolate
- Banana Pudding
- Birthday Cake
- Brownie
- Churro
- Cookie Butter (filled)
- Red Velvet Oreo- $5.50
- Peach Cobbler
- Ultimate Cookies and Cream
- Ultimate Snickers
- Ultimate Twix
- Strawberry Crunch
- Strawberry S'mores
- Strawberry Glaze
WARNING: Please be advised that food prepared may contain these ingredients: milk, eggs, wheat, soybean, peanuts, tree nuts. All sales are final. NO REFUNDS.
Specialty Items
Chocolate Dipped Treats & More
Chocolate Dipped Strawberries
1/2 Dozen- Dipped & Drizzled - $20 W/one topping - $30
(White,Milk, or Dark)
Starts at $45 per dozen
Additional Toppings Available ($5)
- Crushed Almonds or Pecans
- Mini M&Ms
- Oreos
- Fruity Pebbles
- Reese's
- Chocolate Chip Cookie crumbs
- Cookie Butter
- Biscoff Cookie Crumbs
- Turtle Insipred
Cakesickles
$35/dozen
Starts at $30 per dozen
Lettering/ Words -$5
Edible Glitter -$3
Flavors:
- Red Velvet
- Chocolate
- Vanilla
- Carrot
- Lemon
- Strawberry
- Birthday Cake
Frostings:
- Chocolate
- Vanilla
- Cheesecake
- Caramel
- Strawberry
Candied Grapes
Small Grape Tray - 1flavor-$35
Medium Tray- 2flavors -$45
Large Tray -2 flavors -$55
Flavors:
- Blue Raspberry
- Blueberry
- Raspberry
- Tropical Punch
- Strawberry
- Watermelon
- Mango
- Peach
- Pina Colada
- Grape
- Green Apple
- Cotton Candy
- Pineapple
Extra Flavors- $3
Toppings:
- Jolly Rancher Dust
- Starbursts/ Sour Starbursts
- Skittles/ Sour Skittles
- Smoothie Skittles
- Nerds
- Airhead Strips
- Lemonheads
- Hi Chew Blend
- Fruit Roll-Up- ($4)
- Paradise Punch
- Caramel Apple
- Sour Power
- Mystery Topping
Additional Topping - $4
Candied Pineapples
Small Pineapple Tray (5 slices of pineapple) -$35 (one flavor & one topping )
Large Pineapple Tray (10 slices of pineapple) -$50 (two flavors & one topping)
Flavors:
- Blue Raspberry
- Raspberry
- Tropical Punch
- Strawberry
- Watermelon
- Mango
- Peach
- Grape
- Green Apple
- Cotton Candy
- Pineapple
Additional Flavors -$3
Toppings:
- Jolly Rancher Dust
- Starbursts
- Skittles
- Nerds
- Airhead Bites
- Lemonheads
- Fruit Roll Up-($5)
- Candy Blast
- Paradise Punch
- Caramel Apple
- Lemonade
- Custom Mix
Candied Fruit Duo Trays
Tropical Tasters - 2 fruit roll up pineapple slices,4 strawberries, 12 grapes fully coated, and 10 mango chunks- $60 (1/2 order comes with candied topping)
Small Duo Tray - (2 pineapple slices + grapes)- $35(1/2 order with candied topping)
Medium Duo Tray - (5 pineapple slices + grapes)- $45 (1/2 order with candied topping)
Large Duo Tray- (8 pineapple slices + grapes- $55 (1/2 order comes with candied topping)
Duo Tray -(8 strawberries + 6 Pineapple Slices)-$50
Packages We Offer ( Chocolate Dipped & Candied Treats )
Need Something for An Event, Baby shower, School Event, Graduation ? Look Below
Package #1 $280
Package #1 :
- 12 Cake Pops
- 12 Chocolate Covered Oreos
- 12 Chocolate Covered Rice Krispie Treats
- 12 Chocolate Covered Pretzel Rods
* Individually Wrapped -$30
Package #2 $380
Party Package #2:
- 24 Cake Pops
- 24 Chocolate Covered Oreos
- 24 Chocolate Covered Rice Krispie Treats
- 36 Chocolate Covered Pretzel Rods
*Individually Wrapped-$40
Candied Fruit Package #1 4Way Split $75
- 6 Pineapple Rings
- 6 Mango Slices
- 6 Strawberries
- 25-30 Grapes
Fruit Roll Up Wrapped - $7
Extra Topping -$7
Extra Flavor-$10
Toppings:
- Lemonade
- Jolly Rancher Mix
- Tropical Jolly Rancher Mix
- Hi-chew Blend
- Unicorn Crown
- Nerds
- Starbursts
- OG Skittles or Sour Skittles
- Airheads
- Sour Fruit Roll Ups
- Custom
Package #2 $80 (Grapes Only)One Flavor & Two Toppings
- 30-40 Grapes
Fruit Roll Up Wrapped - $7
Extra Topping -$7
Extra Flavor-$10
Toppings:
- Lemonade
- Jolly Rancher Mix
- Tropical Jolly Rancher Mix
- Hi-chew Blend
- Sour Fruit Roll Ups
- Unicorn Crown
- Nerds
- Starbursts
- OG Skittles or Sour Skittles
- Airheads
- Mystery
- Custom
Package #3 $85 (Two flavors & two toppings)
- 10 Pineapple Rings
- 12 Strawberries
- 30-40 Grapes
Color Themed- $12
Fruit Roll Up- $5
Extra Topping -$7
Extra Flavor- $10
- Lemonade
- Jolly Rancher Mix
- Tropical Jolly Rancher Mix
- Hi-chew Blend
- Unicorn Crown
- Nerds
- Starbursts
- OG Skittles or Sour Skittles
- Airheads
- Sour Power
- Mystery
- Custom
Package #3 $95 (Grapes Only)Two Flavors & Two Toppings
- 70-80 Grapes
Fruit Roll Up Wrapped - $7
Extra Topping -$7
Extra Flavor-$10
Toppings:
- Lemonade
- Jolly Rancher Mix
- Tropical Jolly Rancher Mix
- Hi-chew Blend
- Sour Fruit Roll Ups
- Unicorn Crown
- Nerds
- Starbursts
- OG Skittles or Sour Skittles
- Airheads
- Mystery
- Custom
Package #7 $105 (Fruit Roll-Up Wrapped Party Pack)
- 12 Pineapple Rings
- 6-8 Mango Chunks
- 4 Strawberries
- 50-60 Grapes
Extra Topping-$7
Extra Topping -$10
Toppings:
- Lemonade
- Jolly Rancher Mix
- Tropical Jolly Rancher Mix
- Hi-chew Blend
- Unicorn Crown
- Nerds
- Starbursts
- OG Skittles or Sour Skittles
- Airheads
- Mystery
- Sour Fruit Roll Ups
- Custom
*Please list any allergies or dietary restrictions with order*
Gourmet Cookie Shipping Now Available
Shipping Days are Tuesday and Friday Mornings
Shipping Price: $15.00